Thoughts on the Proper Role of Ideology in Politics

ideology

A few weeks ago, I participated in the following conversation on Twitter, which has had me thinking about the proper role of ideology in politics ever since.  It began with a tweet from Jeremy Votaw about how he was tired of dealing with ideologues.  Blogger Connor Boyack joined in, and things proceeded from there:

@curtbentley
Me too. But I’m pretty sure we’ve always been a nation of ideologues, occasionally forced into compromise @jeremyvotaw #utpol

@cboyack
@curtbentley @jeremyvotaw How inconvenient, that ideology stuff. Great things, continual compromise has brought us…

@curtbentley
@cboyack @jeremyvotaw Ideology does all the reasoning up front in the abstract and ignores real world implications.

@cboyack
@curtbentley @jeremyvotaw It doesn’t ignore it. It just advocates principled solutions that few are willing to embrace.

@curtbentley
@cboyack @jeremyvotaw With emphasis on the “principle” and less emphasis on the “solution”

@cboyack
@jeremyvotaw . . . I simply argue that principle should not be sacrificed in pursuit of “solution” simply because it’s agreeable.

[Continue Reading...]

Some Thoughts on the Utah Caucus System

utah-capitol-slider

A little while ago, I attended a “Meet the Candidates” event sponsored by the Republican Women of Northern Utah designed to introduce state delegates to the candidates for Davis County Republican Party leadership positions in advance of the county organizing convention on April 22, 2011.  The meeting was generally what you would expect: conventional,  uncontroversial, and therefore largely uninteresting, though I did think a couple of the candidates distinguished themselves (no, I won’t say who, because I’m not a delegate and am therefore (almost) totally excluded from the process).[Continue Reading...]